BY MARK SCHOLZ, MD
Prostate
cancer screening presents a unique challenge.
Prostate cancer is a very common, but only a minority of cases are
deadly. This creates a serious problem. It’s good to detect high-grade
disease because early treatment reduces mortality. But PSA screening detects a lot of men with low-grade disease and these men are
harmed. Why? Well-intentioned but over-enthusiastic doctors recommend treatment
even though it’s truly medically unnecessary.
Why We Over Diagnose
So
what can be done? Physician propensity
for overtreatment will only change slowly. The shortest pathway out of this
dilemma is to stop diagnosing so much low-grade disease. The crux of the
problem is the random needle biopsy, a “blind” procedure that is widely considered
to be the necessary first step for evaluating elevated PSA. A million men undergo biopsy annually;
250,000 men are diagnosed; around a 100,000 have low-grade disease the can be
safely monitored with “active surveillance.”
The Next Evolutionary Step
Three-Tesla
multiparametric MRI (MP-MRI) scans developed by Siemens, Philips and GE can reliably
detect high-grade disease without over diagnosing low-grade disease; these scanners
accurately differentiate high-grade from low-grade tumors. The
availability of these new scanners makes random biopsy as currently utilized by
most urologists archaic. Random biopsy involves inserting 12 needles into the
rectum. Beyond its propensity for over-diagnosis,
3% of men are hospitalized with serious infections. Also, it is relatively inaccurate, failing to
detect high grade disease over 15% of the time.
New Technology Growing
Pains
Most internists
and urologists are still unaware of these important technological
advances. Even those who are aware are
still learning how to translate these new imaging reports into practical recommendations
for their patients. Also, there is the challenge of maintaining quality control
in this rapidly expanding world. Despite
these barriers the advantages of using imaging as a first step can’t be
ignored. PCRI has posted a list of centers that perform this type of imaging.
While we have some familiarity with these centers, for liability reasons
we are unable to offer any official certification of their quality and
accuracy. On the other hand, new as this
technology is, we feel it would be a disservice not to spread the word about
its availability.
CHECK OUT THIS VIDEO: SO YOUR PSA IS HIGH, NOW WHAT? http://youtu.be/6QgcfVBzFNs
1 comment:
I'm glad to see the continued push for 3T MRI awareness. The folks over on Inspire/UsToo have been maintaining a list of 3T MRI providers for a few years now and it is quite comprehensive.
http://www.inspire.com/groups/us-too-prostate-cancer/discussion/new-locations-for-3t-mri-guided-biopsy/
The next push needs to be for focal therapies such as FLA/LITT and MRgFUS. It's the 21st Century!
Post a Comment